John Melville-Smith

Partner

Background & Biography

John is a Partner in our Dispute Resolution team, with over 20 years’ experience, particularly in challenges to wills, contested probate and inheritance disputes, commercial partnership and contract disputes, professional negligence, insolvency and debt recovery.

John has a reputation for giving his clients candid and clear advice both on the prospects of success in law and on the commercial realities of the situation.

Career Highlights

He is experienced in negotiating settlements from positions of both strength and weakness and always advises his clients to seek a negotiated or mediated settlement in preference to incurring the costs and uncertainties of trial.

Wherever possible, he conducts his own advocacy, in both the County and High Courts, and has conducted many trials himself, mainly of fast track contract disputes in the County Court.

John is a member of the Association of Contentious Trusts and Probate Specialists (‘ACTAPS’).

Languages
French
2006 – Present | Seddons, Partner
1999 – 2005 | Gillanders, Partner and Head of Litigation
1996 – 1999 | John Martlew & Co, Assistant Solicitor
1994 – 1996 | John Martlew & Co, Trainee

Successfully challenging a homemade will made by the deceased leaving her estate to (and drafted by) her occasional gardener six months after another, professionally-prepared one, leaving it to her closest friend,

Securing the removal of an executor who had moved into the deceased’s house and was failing to administer the estate for the benefit of all its beneficiaries.

Acting for the daughters of the deceased faced with a claim by their brother under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975. Defeating the claim by reason of the will being found to have provided reasonably for the brother who had a chronic gambling addiction.

Acting for the foreign-resident beneficiaries of a UK estate in defending proceedings under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 brought by a woman who claimed that her exclusion from his will was unreasonable in that she had been both maintained by the deceased and sexually abused by him as a child. Negotiating a settlement of the claim.

Advising the widow of a deceased man with regard to her rights under a discretionary trust set up during his lifetime.

Acting for a private prep school in the recovery of fees from parents who claimed that the fees were not due by reason of their having been waived and failure to provide a bursary. Conducting the trial of the matter personally, obtaining judgment for the school and recovery of 95% of its legal costs.

Defending a partner in a defunct property development partnership. Successfully proving that the partnership had been loss-making with the result that no sums were due to the ex-partner and obtaining indemnity costs for the whole action.

Acting for a major mortgage lender seeking judgment for the account shortfalls post-sale and defending allegations of undervalue sales.

Bradshaw v Hardcastle [2002] All ER (D) 219 (Nov)
Ashkettle v Gwinnett [2013] EWHC 2125
Dass v Beggs [2014] EWHC 164
Moursi v Doherty [2019] EWHC 830 (Ch)
Brown v New Quadrant Trust Corporation Ltd [2021] EWHC 1731 (Ch)
Abadir v Credit Suisse Trust Ltd [2021] EWHC 2573 (Ch)
Shirazi v Susa Holdings Establishment [2022] EWHC 477 (Ch)
Shirazi v Susa Holdings Establishment [2022] EWHC 2055 (Ch)

What Our
Clients Say

Hear from our clients about their experiences working with John
Quotation marks icon
I was recommended this company and am So glad I was .Mr John Melville -Smith acted on my behalf in a very difficult case . He was amazing.always very professional and certainly knows his stuff. Cannot thank him enough.
Cheryl B
We received a great service from John Melville-Smith at Seddons and his team. Very thorough, to the point and achieved what we needed with a complex probate matter. Would highly recommend John and his team.
Anonymous
Had the pleasure of being assigned to John Melville-Smith for our property cases for approximately 3 years. We had local solicitors previously but when we were introduced to John it was like a whole different kettle of fish, a breath of fresh air. We felt supported, defended, that John cared and wanted justice for the truth. He did above and beyond to fight our corner and he figured out the other parties pretty quickly. We felt safe and trusted John completely. He was always honest and to the point but he knew from the start what he was dealing with and he defended us so well. He wasn’t afraid to stand up for usWe cannot thank John enough for his professionalism, attention to detail, for being there for us at some very dark moments and for being the Solicitor to help us succeed. His whit and charm throughout definitely helped put smiles on our faces when needed. Would happily recommend John and Seddons to anyone who needs a fantastic legal service, and already have done. Thank you John. From all of the Udunuwara family.
Cheryl U

Our Thinking

Our legal experts are often asked to share their insight on recent developments in certain areas of the law.

IHT and Pension reforms: an update

Read more

Insights, Private Client

December 11, 2025

Philip Kratz and Negina Maihanwal Feature in Estates Gazette

Read more

In the press

December 1, 2025

The Autumn Budget 2025: What It Means from a Private Client Perspective

Read more

Private Client, Insights

November 28, 2025

Moshe Moses Features in the Telegraph

Read more

In the press, Residential Real Estate

November 25, 2025

Companies House – New Identity Verification

Read more

Insights

November 14, 2025

James Cohen Features in Spear’s

Read more

In the press

October 29, 2025

Odein Willie-Harry Features in Taxation

Read more

In the press

October 24, 2025

Alice Robertson Features in EPrivateClient

Read more

In the press

October 16, 2025

Seddons GSC Recognised by Legal 500 UK Rankings 2025

Read more

Firm news

October 2, 2025

James Cohen Features in the Jerusalem Post

Read more

In the press

September 15, 2025

Philip Kratz Features in Yahoo!News UK

Read more

In the press

September 15, 2025

Informed Consent for Lens Replacement Surgery: Does it Really Provide the Outcome that is Being Sold?

Read more

Insights

September 12, 2025

James Cohen Features in CoStar

Read more

In the press

September 3, 2025

Inheritance Tax and Business Property Relief – Planning for Change

Read more

Insights

August 27, 2025

Navigating Common Challenges with Immigration Bail Conditions

Read more

Insights

August 26, 2025

Saleem Sheikh features in The I Paper

Read more

In the press

August 26, 2025

IHT and Pension Reforms: Navigating the New Landscape

Read more

Insights, Seddons GSC

August 22, 2025

Upper Tribunal Decision Upholds Refusal for Woman’s Indefinite Leave to Remain

Read more

Insights

August 21, 2025

Saleem Sheikh features in Asian Voice

Read more

In the press

August 14, 2025

Neil Russell Joins Ali Miraj on LBC

Read more

Seddons GSC

August 4, 2025

The Standish Shift: Family Law’s New Balancing Act

Read more

Insights

July 18, 2025

Ross Waldram Features in the City A.M. Newsletter

Read more

Seddons GSC

July 17, 2025

John Midgley Features in The Negotiator

Read more

In the press

July 8, 2025

John Midgley at the Apartment Advisor Awards

Read more

Firm news

July 7, 2025

Neil Russell Joins Nick Ferrari on LBC

Read more

In the press

July 7, 2025

Key Changes to Immigration Rules, What You Need to Know in 2025

Read more

Insights

July 1, 2025

Zoe Pearse TEP Features in The Sunday Times

Read more

In the press

June 30, 2025

Catherine Hancock Features in The Times

Read more

In the press

June 26, 2025

Natasha Southam Features in The Telegraph

Read more

In the press

June 23, 2025

James Cohen features in Citywealth

Read more

In the press

June 11, 2025

Neil Russell joins Daniel Barnett on LBC

Read more

In the press

June 9, 2025

Planning for incapacity – Zoe Pearse writes for STEP Journal

Read more

In the press

June 6, 2025

James Cohen Features in the Telegraph

Read more

In the press

June 5, 2025

Why International Students are Turning to the UK Amid Rising US Visa Uncertainty

Read more

Insights

May 29, 2025

Thinking About Moving to the UK from the US? Here’s What to Consider

Read more

Insights

May 27, 2025

The Law Commission’s Modernizing Wills Law Report: Recommended Reform

Read more

Insights

May 22, 2025

Ben Menahem Features in the Telegraph

Read more

Seddons GSC

May 21, 2025

Seddons GSC advises Enviroo on significant equity and debt investment by Reichmuth Infrastructure

Read more

Firm news

May 19, 2025

James Cohen features in Citywealth discussing why the world’s wealthiest families are falling apart

Read more

In the press

May 16, 2025

Stuart Crippin features in Spear’s discussing whether the UK can turn tide on the recent increase in UHNW departures from the UK

Read more

In the press

May 15, 2025

Reforming UK Immigration: A Closer Look at the 2025 White Paper for Workers and Students

Read more

Insights

May 14, 2025

Settlement Under Strain: What the 10-Year ILR Reform Means for Migrants

Read more

Insights

May 14, 2025

Seddons GSC advises Rupal and Ravindra Patel on the acquisition of a second Winkworth franchise

Read more

Firm news

May 12, 2025

Seddons GSC acts for Caroline Hirons’ Skin Rocks in Series A investment

Read more

Firm news

May 1, 2025

Ben Menahem Features in the Telegraph

Read more

In the press

April 28, 2025

Simon Ross and Saleem Sheikh feature in Legal Practice Management Magazine April 25

Read more

In the press

April 16, 2025

Howard Freeman Joins Matthew Wright on LBC

Read more

In the press

April 2, 2025

London law firms Seddons and GSC Solicitors complete merger to launch £22m full-service firm Seddons GSC

Read more

Firm news

April 1, 2025

Promotion Announcements

Read more

Seddons GSC

March 28, 2025

Helen Crossland features in The Times

Read more

Seddons GSC

March 27, 2025

Seddons GSC. Experience matters.

If you need legal advice, get in touch with one of our experts. We will get back to you as soon as possible.